Welcome to Penny House Cafe
Penny House Cafe is a charming and cozy spot nestled in Brooklyn, NY, known for its warm ambiance and exceptional service. With a focus on quality, this delightful cafe offers a menu brimming with delectable options, including their renowned breakfast bagel sandwiches and a variety of fresh pastries. The attentive staff, led by the personable owner, Mahmoud, consistently delivers top-notch, friendly service, making patrons feel right at home. Guests rave about the inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying their superb coffee and delightful treats like lemon olive cake and chocolate croissants. Penny House Cafe is truly a hidden gem worth visiting.
Penny House Cafe: Reviews & Ratings
Penny House Cafe is a gem! Mah was incredibly friendly and personable, making us feel right at home. We tried their best seller and supreme sandwiches, and they were absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made. The warm atmosphere and amazing service will definitely bring us back. Highly recommend!
Penny House Cafe is the real deal! Amazing coffee, delicious pastries, and a chill atmosphere that makes you want to stay. Mahmoud runs this place with top-tier service, friendly, fast, and all about quality. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a go-to cafe!
Penny House Cafe made our experience here amazing. They treated us with open arms and recommended a few options to try, not overselling, but caring and loving what they do. Our soft hot bagel breakfast sandwiches were delicious. Coffee was on point, and we are glad we made this trip to come try them out. The lemon olive cake, blue berry muffin, and chocolate croissant uffffff no words needed. Thanks to the 2 of you, we wanted to go back, but time didn't permit. Hopefully, we'll be back soon. Keep up the amazing customer service, many places need to learn from the 2 of you.
Really charming and cozy cafe / deli near prospect park. A couple of seating & pretty narrow place. There’s one cook and one manning the cash register so expect your order to take a while. However, while you wait there are free wifi and attentive service to distract you!
Had the best breakfast bagel sandwich I’ve ever had. The owner is very personable and the atmosphere is friendly and inviting. I highly recommend Penny House.
Had the absolute pleasure of coming into Penny House Cafe recently. I got the best seller and drip coffee. The food portion was great and delicious! But the star of it all was the owner, he was so warm and hospitable despite a busy line, really made sure everyone was taken care of. Good hospitality is hard to find in this town, definitely worth a visit!
This place is warm and very friendly! I came in for an Earl Grey tea with oat milk steamed and it was prepared delicious and perfect. What really caught my eye attention was that they have all their cakes and cookies and croissants NEATLY, WRAPPED AND COVERED! I love to see that. The cookies, muffins, croissants are all neatly wrapped and covered. Most cafes do not cover their food and just place them open behind a glass where germs or flies can get to it. I never understood that. The owner and the lady that made my tea were very nice. The space is nice and cozy to sit and eat their beautifully prepared food or just have a warm or cold drink. This place is awesome!!
Excellent food, staff, and vibes. Perfect for an early morning sammy and some delicious coffee. Thank you!
Location
-
732 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States Hotline: +1 347-240-7281
Welcome to Penny House Cafe, a delightful gem nestled at 732 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238. This charming cafe has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike, thanks to its warm atmosphere and impeccable service. As you step inside, you are greeted by the friendly faces of the staff, particularly the affable owner, Mahmoud, who is known for making everyone feel right at home.
The menu is a showcase of fresh, flavorful offerings, with standout items such as their best-selling sandwiches and enticing breakfast bagels that have earned rave reviews. Customer James Ting praised the "supreme sandwiches," highlighting their perfect construction and bursts of flavor. Each bite is a reminder of the cafe’s commitment to quality ingredients and skillful preparation.
But it’s not just the sandwiches that shine here. The coffee, expertly brewed, pairs beautifully with an array of delectable pastries. Marc-Elie notes the cafe’s amazing coffee and chill ambiance; it’s a space designed for both relaxation and enjoyment, perfect for catching up with friends or diving into a good book. The carefully crafted lemon olive cake, blueberry muffins, and rich chocolate croissants, as noted by Gonzalo Alvarado, are irresistible delights that elevate any visit to Penny House Cafe.
The cafe’s size may be cozy, offering limited seating, but this only adds to its charm, creating an intimate dining experience. While you may need to be patient during busier times, the attentive service and free Wi-Fi provide excellent distractions while you wait. Elaine’s review echoes this sentiment, providing insight into the nurturing environment that makes you want to linger a little longer in the cozy corners of the cafe.
In essence, Penny House Cafe is not just a place to grab a quick bite; it’s about savoring quality food in a welcoming setting. With each sandwich, pastry, and cup of coffee, you’re not just enjoying a meal—you’re experiencing warmth, community, and the very essence of good hospitality. It’s a culinary haven that invites you back time and again, solidifying its place among Brooklyn’s must-visit cafes.
Whether you’re a longtime resident or a first-time visitor, make sure to stop by Penny House Cafe. Your taste buds will thank you, and you might just find a new home-away-from-home!